Wednesday,
April 20, 2005 11:54 PM
Jump Raises -
Majors
PITBULLS:
I
do not like the Bergen structure for major suit raises . The 3♣/3♦ bids are clumsy and the 4 bids are downright
silly. I also do not like the jump raise as pre-emptive as Bergen does. If you
are going to pre-empt , bid 4 of a major ! This bid puts maximum pressure on
the opponents and really pre-empts the auction . What I really like about the
Bergen treatment is the simple raise
showing 3 card support.
However
I think this philosophy , if you will ,
should be applied for all simple raises.
Whether in response to an overcall or after a takeout double or passed hand or
directly , all
simple raises show 3 trump period. OK what do you do with a simple raise with 4
trump ? This hand with 4 trump is the jump raise in competition , after
partner’s overcall and directly. I think it is far more important to announce
to partner immediately that you have 4 trump. The law of total tricks kicks in.
You can judge the auction so much better when you know there is 4 trump over
there.
The
only exception would be in 3rd seat when you open 4 card majors
frequently. You then can get away with a simple raise showing 4 trump. Even
then , going to the 3 level is not a disaster. In competitive auctions when you
have 4 trump to partners overcall or opening bid , I would hazard a guess that
90% of the auctions get pushed to the 3 level anyway. When you have a 9 card fit they are short in your suit and
will compete to the 3 level. Why not get the auction up to the 3 level fast not as a pre-empt but
to tell partner about the 4th trump ? You jam the opponents and give
valuable information to partner at the same time.
If
you have the 4 th trump and compensating HCP’s you do not need much of an
excuse to make a limit raise or Q bid showing a limit raise or better. Axxx
xx KJxxx xx
is a limit raise to partner spade overcall or opening bid . Change the
hand slightly Axxx xx Qxxxx xx
and it’s a 3 spade bid in competition or directly. Change it again to Axx
xx KJxxx xxx and it becomes a two spade
bid.
The
4th trump has to be biddable
somehow. Making it an integral part of a
jump raise is
a good way of bidding it in my opinion. I now cringe when partner makes a
simple raise and puts down 4 trump . This bidding defies the law of total
tricks and is not describing his hand correctly. Bid your 4th trump
! I think a simple raise with 4 trump is a hangover from opening 4 card majors. Playing 5 card
majors you have a 9 card fit and the law of total tricks says you should be
able to make a 3 level contract. If partner makes a weak jump overcall or weak
two and you have 4 trump you have no qualms about getting the auction to the 4
level so why not the 3 level with 9 trump ?
Tom
and I make our forcing raises in
the minors and majors as limit raise or better.
This frees up a jump raise for a different purpose. I think making it
pre-emptive is a waste & redundant as you have a jump to game as
pre-emptive. Define the jump bid as a simple raise with 4 trump. Tom and I had
a 3♦
bid reserved for a good simple raise with 4 trump ( just under a limit raise )
so a jump raise is just under those values and we are really splitting hairs.
Tom had xxxx Axx xxxx Qxx which is not quite enough for 3♦ with our methods but it is a fine 3♠ bid after I opened 1
spade.